MNsure_TheCircle_1800x150

Indigenous Journalists Association Condemns Albuquerque Journal Cartoon of Deb Haaland

Writer
Share :
Facebook
X
A black-and-white political cartoon shows Deb Haaland standing beside a sign reading “1st Native American woman governor.” She is drawn with exaggerated facial features. A man wearing a New Mexico hat says, “Yes, congratulations on that! Now let’s talk about our being 50th on the totem pole…” The cartoon uses a totem-pole reference as a political joke about Haaland’s election.
MNsure_TheCircle_1800x150

The Indigenous Journalists Association (IJA) is calling on the Albuquerque Journal to apologize and review its editorial process after the newspaper published a cartoon of New Mexico Gov.-elect Deb Haaland, a citizen of the Pueblo of Laguna.

The cartoon, by staff cartoonist John Trever, appeared in the Journal’s Sunday, Nov. 8, print edition. IJA said it used a “totem pole” reference to make Haaland’s Indigenous identity a punch line, misattributing a cultural practice of Pacific Northwest tribes to a Pueblo woman. The association said the cartoon reinforced the false idea that Indigenous peoples and cultures are interchangeable.

IJA acknowledged that political cartoonists may scrutinize Haaland’s record and proposals. But it said editors are responsible for what the newspaper publishes, and political commentary should hold public officials accountable without reducing them to racial caricatures.

The association is asking the Journal to publish an apology in print and online, explain how the cartoon passed editorial review, provide staff education on reporting about Indigenous communities, and use resources such as IJA’s Indigenous Media Initiative.

The New Mexico Political Report noted that the newspaper has faced criticism before over its coverage of Haaland and recalled a 2018 controversy involving a syndicated cartoon about young immigrants. It reported that, as of Nov. 14, the Journal had not publicly responded to IJA’s requests.

IJA said Native people are among the newspaper’s readers, sources and neighbors, and deserve the same care, accuracy and respect as every community.

Sources

Writer,
General News
Miiskogihmiiwan “Miisko” Poupart-Chapman is a Dakota and Ojibwe writer, artist, and social media coordinator for The Circle. She is Dakota from the Sisseton Wahpeton Oyate, an enrolled member of the Lac du Flambeau Band of Lake Superior Chippewa, and Bear Clan. Her work celebrates Indigenous voices, creativity, and community.

This reporting is made possible by readers like you.

The Circle is a nonprofit newsroom with no tribal affiliation, no corporate ownership, and no paywall. Independent Native journalism depends on reader support.

Advertisement

GDG The Circle 160x550px

Recent Stories

Advertisement

MNsure_TheCircle_1000x2110

More From National BriefsNews

Documentary ‘Nine Little Indians’ to Screen at Turtle Mountain During Native American Heritage Month

The Turtle Mountain Band of Chippewa Indians will host a screening of the documentary Nine Little Indians on November 17 at the Sky Dancer Event Center in Belcourt, North Dakota, highlighting the experiences of nine Native sisters who survived abuse in the American Indian boarding school system. Directed by award-winning filmmaker Shannon Kring and executive […]

Honoring Native American Veterans: A Legacy of Service and Sacrifice

As communities across the country observe Veterans Day on November 11th, The Circle joins tribal nations in honoring the Native American men and women who have served, and continue to serve, in the United States Armed Forces. Native Americans have a long history of military service, with participation rates historically among the highest of any […]

A hand holds Tipiziwin Tolman’s deer-hide medicine pouches, which contain íŋyaŋ wóawaŋyaŋke (protection rock), according to CBC.(Left) Tipiziwin Tolman stands beside a display, wearing her medicine pouches around her neck.(Right)

Alaska Airlines Passenger Says She Was Told to Remove Sacred Medicine Pouches

Tipiziwin Tolman, a Dakota and Lakota student from the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe, says a flight attendant on an Alaska Airlines flight from Seattle to Vancouver told her to remove the medicine pouches she wore around her neck or leave the plane. Tolman was traveling to a First Nations Language Keepers conference in Saskatoon. She […]

MNsure_TheCircle_1800x150

Search The Circle

Find stories, columns, events, and magazine features.

Help The Circle Recover & Preserve Native History

FIRE RECOVERY & ARCHIVE PRESERVATION FUND

A recent fire at the building housing The Circle’s office has created unexpected challenges for our independent Native newspaper.

Thankfully, with the help of community members, we were able to recover our newspaper archives dating back to the 1980s. These irreplaceable records preserve decades of Native community history, cultural knowledge, and stories.

Your donation will help The Circle recover from the fire, protect our historical archives, and continue sharing Native voices for generations to come.

Every contribution makes a difference.

Pinagigi — Thank you for helping preserve generations of Native stories.