MNsure_TheCircle_1800x150

Federal appeals court backs tribal authority in Kalshi sports-betting dispute

Writer
Share :
Facebook
X
MNsure_TheCircle_1800x150

A federal appeals court has handed two California tribes a significant victory in their challenge to Kalshi, ruling that the company’s online sports event contracts likely violate federal Indian gaming law when accessed from tribal lands.

In a unanimous decision issued Sept. 16, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reversed part of a lower court ruling that denied preliminary injunctive relief to Blue Lake Rancheria and Chicken Ranch Rancheria of Me-Wuk Indians.

The tribes sued Kalshi and Robinhood, arguing that contracts allowing customers to place money on the outcomes of sporting events constitute unauthorized Class III gaming under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act, or IGRA.

The appellate court concluded that the tribes were likely to succeed on their IGRA claims. It found that Kalshi’s sports event contracts constitute Class III gaming activity and that the activity is located on Indian lands when users enter into the contracts from tribal territory.

The court also rejected Kalshi’s argument that federal commodities law displaces IGRA in this context. Kalshi maintains that its contracts are financial products regulated exclusively by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, not gambling subject to tribal or state regulation.

“The CEA and IGRA address two different questions,” Judge M. Margaret McKeown wrote for the panel. The Commodity Exchange Act regulates derivatives trading on designated markets, while IGRA governs Class III gaming activity on Indian lands.

The Ninth Circuit sent the case back to the federal district court to evaluate the remaining requirements for issuing a preliminary injunction. The ruling does not finally resolve the lawsuit. The appellate court also upheld the rejection of the tribes’ false-advertising claim under the Lanham Act.

Although the decision arose in California, it addresses many of the same questions presented in a separate lawsuit brought by the Ho-Chunk Nation in Wisconsin.

The Ho-Chunk Nation sued Kalshi and Robinhood in August 2025, alleging that their sports event contracts amount to unauthorized gaming when accessed from the Nation’s lands. The Nation argues that the activity violates IGRA, interferes with its sovereign regulatory authority, and diverts revenue that supports tribal government programs and services.

In May, U.S. District Judge William Conley allowed the Nation’s central IGRA claims against Kalshi to proceed. Conley found that the Nation demonstrated a likelihood of success on those claims but denied its request for a preliminary injunction because it had not shown irreparable harm. The court dismissed Robinhood from the lawsuit, along with the Nation’s false-advertising and racketeering claims.

On Sept. 11, Conley certified two legal questions for a potential immediate appeal to the Seventh Circuit. Those questions concern whether violations of tribal gaming ordinances are actionable under IGRA and whether the Commodity Exchange Act prevents tribes from challenging contracts traded on federally regulated markets.

Kalshi must ask the Seventh Circuit for permission to pursue that appeal. The Wisconsin court ordered the case stayed if the company seeks appellate review expeditiously.

Because Wisconsin falls within the Seventh Circuit, the Ninth Circuit’s decision is not binding in the Ho-Chunk Nation case. It may nevertheless provide persuasive support because the California court rejected many of the same arguments Kalshi is making in Wisconsin.

Kalshi has maintained that its products are federally regulated event contracts, not sports bets. A company spokesperson told Reuters that Kalshi may appeal the Ninth Circuit ruling.

The cases are part of a widening national dispute over whether prediction markets can offer sports-related contracts without complying with state and tribal gaming laws—and whether federal commodities regulation overrides the sovereign authority tribes exercise over gaming on their lands.

Sources:

Writer,
General News
Victoria Fox is an enrolled member of the Ho-Chunk Nation and a communications and operations professional with a background in administration, community outreach, and organizational support. She is passionate about helping lead The Circle into its next chapter while honoring its longstanding legacy of independent Indigenous journalism and advocacy.

This reporting is made possible by readers like you.

The Circle is a nonprofit newsroom with no tribal affiliation, no corporate ownership, and no paywall. Independent Native journalism depends on reader support.

Advertisement

MNsure_TheCircle_1000x2110

Recent Stories

Advertisement

MNsure_TheCircle_1000x2110

More From Business & EconomyNational BriefsNewsPolitics & Policy

A black-and-white political cartoon shows Deb Haaland standing beside a sign reading “1st Native American woman governor.” She is drawn with exaggerated facial features. A man wearing a New Mexico hat says, “Yes, congratulations on that! Now let’s talk about our being 50th on the totem pole…” The cartoon uses a totem-pole reference as a political joke about Haaland’s election.

Indigenous Journalists Association Condemns Albuquerque Journal Cartoon of Deb Haaland

The Indigenous Journalists Association (IJA) is calling on the Albuquerque Journal to apologize and review its editorial process after the newspaper published a cartoon of New Mexico Gov.-elect Deb Haaland, a citizen of the Pueblo of Laguna. The cartoon, by staff cartoonist John Trever, appeared in the Journal’s Sunday, Nov. 8, print edition. IJA said […]

Documentary ‘Nine Little Indians’ to Screen at Turtle Mountain During Native American Heritage Month

The Turtle Mountain Band of Chippewa Indians will host a screening of the documentary Nine Little Indians on November 17 at the Sky Dancer Event Center in Belcourt, North Dakota, highlighting the experiences of nine Native sisters who survived abuse in the American Indian boarding school system. Directed by award-winning filmmaker Shannon Kring and executive […]

Honoring Native American Veterans: A Legacy of Service and Sacrifice

As communities across the country observe Veterans Day on November 11th, The Circle joins tribal nations in honoring the Native American men and women who have served, and continue to serve, in the United States Armed Forces. Native Americans have a long history of military service, with participation rates historically among the highest of any […]

MNsure_TheCircle_1800x150

Search The Circle

Find stories, columns, events, and magazine features.

Help The Circle Recover & Preserve Native History

FIRE RECOVERY & ARCHIVE PRESERVATION FUND

A recent fire at the building housing The Circle’s office has created unexpected challenges for our independent Native newspaper.

Thankfully, with the help of community members, we were able to recover our newspaper archives dating back to the 1980s. These irreplaceable records preserve decades of Native community history, cultural knowledge, and stories.

Your donation will help The Circle recover from the fire, protect our historical archives, and continue sharing Native voices for generations to come.

Every contribution makes a difference.

Pinagigi — Thank you for helping preserve generations of Native stories.